| JB McIntire | 1850-53, 1857, 1863, 1870-71 |
| VH Jones | 1854-56, 1858-1862 |
| James P. Kinslow | 1872-73, 1889 |
| Silas Tunks | 1877, 1883-85, 1887, 1890, 1897-98, 1900, 1904, 1909, 1911-12 |
| John E. Blair | 1891 |
| JC Dossey | 1892, 1901-03, 1907-08 |
| Enoch Elijah Parsley | 1894-99 |
| Marvel Mills Logan | 1906 |
| Walter Day Spillman | 1910, 1916-17 |
| Porter B. Spillman | 1913-15, 1918, 1921 |
| OT Mitchell | 1919 |
| ED (Dud) Luttrell | 1922 |
| NE Reed | 1923 |
| Stanford M. Davis | 1924 |
| Willard W. Lindsey | 1925-26 |
| John (Whistler) Vincent | 1927-28, 1930, 1932, 1937, 1939, 1944 |
| TH Demunbrun | 1929 |
| William A. Pardue | 1931 |
| Walter Bunnell | 1933 |
| Walter Davis | 1934 |
| Charles Whittle | 1935-36 |
| Noah Skaggs | 1938 |
| WO Blanton | 1940 |
| Clifford Norene | 1941, 1946 |
| WH (Bottle Bill) Conway | 1942 |
| Fred Bennieweise | 1943 |
| Earl C. Reed | 1945 |
| Raymond Houchins | 1947 |
| GC Reed | 1948 |
| Homer J. Parsley | 1949 |
| Clyde Webb | 1950 |
| Edgar Cooke | 1951 |
| Carl Woodward | 1952 |
| Gus Parsley | 1953 |
| George McCombs, Jr. | 1954 |
| Rick Caswell | 1955 |
| Lon Rich | 1956 |
| No Info | 1957 |
| Garland Houchins | 1958 |
| Roger Rich | 1959 |
| Willie J. Douglas | 1960 |
| Ruble Miller | 1961 |
| George Davis | 1962 |
| Roy T. Vincent | 1963 |
| Kenneth Meredith | 1964 |
| Morris Blanton | 1965 |
| Eugene Basham | 1966 |
| Lowell Davis | 1967 |
| Haskell Lane | 1968 |
| George H. Sowders | 1969 |
| Mack Douglas | 1970 |
| Malcolm Basham | 1971, 1984 |
| Gilbert Douglas | 1972 |
| Mark Ashley | 1973 |
| James H. Newkirk | 1974 |
| Jerry Prunty | 1975 |
| Granvil G. Ashley, Jr. | 1976 |
| Ronnie Lindsey | 1977, 1996 |
| Molton Wallace | 1978 |
| William Freddie Corbitt | 1979 |
| Oval "Pappy" Garner | 1980 |
| Granvil G. Ashley | 1981 |
| John G. Madison | 1982 |
| Ezra Garner | 1983 |
| Gilbert M. Hodge | 1985 |
| Richard Jones | 1986 |
| Chester Carroll | 1987 |
| Alan Browning | 1988 |
| Tommy Hammond | 1989 |
| Howard Stewart | 1990 |
| McNeil VanMeter | 1991 |
| Fonce Skaggs | 1992 |
| Larry Woodcock | 1993, 1997 |
| Terry Wayne Prewitt | 1994 |
| Brad McDougal | 1995 |
| Ron Wolf | 1998 |
| Vern Wolf | 1999 |
| Brent "Tootie" Ashley | 2000 |
| Chester Brooks | 2001 |
| Ronnie Brooks | 2002 |
| Mark Anthony Ashley | 2003 |
| Dan Wolf | 2004 |
| Richard Prewitt | 2005 |
| Leonard "Mike" Knight | 2006 |
| Scott Lindsey | 2007 |